Romanesque art flourished in Europe around 1050 and extended to the 12th century. Gothic art is the name given to the art of the later Middle Ages, especially from the mid-1100s to about 1400. The subjects of artwork in these two periods were similar, but you'll see that the artists used somewhat different approaches...
Romanesque Architecture
During Romanesque times, wealthy monasteries became the most important patrons of the arts. Many churches were built, mural paintings became important, and monumental stone sculpture was revived. Romanesque art continued the Medieval taste for flat space, inorganic figures, and lively decorative stylization.
The Romanesque architectural style was especially well developed in churches and monastic structures. The typical Romanesque church was planned in the shape of a Latin cross—that is, a cross with a vertical arm and a shorter horizontal crosspiece above the center. The roof over the nave (the main gathering area) consisted of vaults of stone constructed on the principle of the arch. Side aisles flanked the nave. Large columns called piers supported the roof vaults. Round arches were built in openings in the walls and between the piers. The openings and piers were decorated with stone sculptures and carvings depicting biblical scenes and people. The walls of the church were painted in fresco and also portrayed religious subjects.
Romanesque Sculpture and Tapestry
Romanesque sculpture developed in relation to the roads used by the pilgrims. The work consisted of reliefs and sculptures applied to the exterior of churches to appeal to the lay worshiper. One of the best examples of Romanesque sculpture is the Autun Cathedral in Burgundy (1120-1135). Gislebertus carved its decoration; he was the only sculptor to sign his name on a Romanesque church. Flat patterns and weightlessness characterize the monumental tympanum (semicircle over the portal of a Romanesque church) at Autun. It represents an imposing figure of Christ appearing in a majestic light at the Last Judgment.
 |
Romanesque sculpture from the Cloister of St. Trophime. The contours of the characters form a series of flattened curves that correspond to the curved arm. |
One of the most intriguing Romanesque works is the so-called Bayeux Tapestry. It depicts the Norman invasion of England in 1066. It is over 230 feet long and contains 626 human figures, 731 animals, 376 boats, and 70 buildings and trees. The Bayeux Tapestry is not really a tapestry, in which designs are generally woven into fabric. Rather, it is a work of embroidery in which designs are stitched with woolen threads on a background of plain cloth. Unlike most Romanesque art, the tapestry is primarily historical instead of religious in its themes.
 |
Detail from the Bayeux Tapestry. Single threads were used for waves, ropes, and strands of hairs on the horses' foreheads, and the outlines of each section of color.
|
Gothic Sculpture
In the Gothic period, universities replaced monasteries as centers of learning and culture. Professional painters and scribes, not monks and nuns, began to paint the illuminations in churches.
Gothic sculpture first appeared at St. Denis and at Chartres cathedrals in France. Romanesque sculpture had been vigorous, dramatic, and abstract. In comparison, Gothic sculpture was calmer, grander, and more humane. One of the greatest Gothic sculptors is Claus Sluter (1379-1406). Sluter was from the Netherlands, but worked for the Duke of Dijon. His most impressive works are The Moses Well (1395-1406) and the Portal of the Chartreuse de Champmol (1385-1393).
 |
Sculpture from the Cathedral of Chartres. The door sculptures are slender, columnar figures of Old Testament kings and queens, therefore the sculpture is called the "Royal Portal." |
Gothic Stained Glass
Gothic painters looked at the entire world, not just human beings. At first, they studied the details of nature, including leaves, flowers, animals, and insects. Then, they painted human beings acting out stories, with the natural world as a backdrop. However, the main subject matter continued to be religious.
 |
Stained glass from Canterbury Cathedral.
|
An important architectural trend at this time was the use of stained glass. The technique of staining glass had been perfected in Romanesque times, but it was during the Gothic period that more complex designs began to be made. Huge stained glass windows were made to create a continuous flood of light to the interior of cathedrals.
Around 1200, stained glass replaced illumination as the leading form of painting. One of the best examples of stained glass work is the Habakkuk (1220) at Bourges cathedral. It is 14 feet tall and represents one of the Old Testament prophets. The work is an amazing jigsaw of hundreds of small pieces of tainted glass bound together by strips of lead.
The artist at Bourges painted with glass, as painters with paint. Smaller details, such as the eyes, are actually painted on the glass surface. The rest of the composition is made by combining and arranging shaped glass fragments.
The development of painting techniques in the Andes during the Spanish Colonial period was important to the Christianization by the Spanish Crown. Painting was solely devoted to religious themes: angels, virgins, saints, and biblical scenes were used to teach the native people about the new religion. Towards the end of the 16th century and the beginning of the 17th, an original interpretation of the European tradition of painting flourished in the Andes.
Murals and Fabric
The diffusion of European painting techniques such as oil painting on panel was difficult in South America because of a lack of materials. Artists had to adapt these techniques to local materials, and they favored painting on fabric and mural techniques.
Painting on fabric was the most commonly used technique during the colonial period. In the beginning, canvas and hemp fabrics were imported from Europe. However, after a while artists started to mix them with locally produced wool and cotton fabric. This gave higher flexibility to the fabric, allowing the artists to send them away to remote communities where they would be stretched on to wooden frames.
Murals were made over a mud surface covered with several layers of talc. This was coated with animal glue and mixed pigments. Murals were generally large scale, and mostly used to decorate church walls.
Influences and Subject Matter
The European style that most influenced Colonial Latin American art was the Baroque style. In Latin America, however, the style was greatly simplified and adapted towards the tastes of the indigenous population. Instead of creating elaborate compositions, painters aimed to create a mystical experience for an audience of South American Indians, who were newly-converted Christians. Painters combined native mythological scenes along with Catholic themes and mostly avoided references to South American scenes. Colonial painters were still dominated by European models and would represent vegetation and animals of other latitudes.
 |
San José with the Child - Gregorio Vásquez de Arce y Ceballos. Note the humble way in which both St Joseph and the child are clad. Jesus is covered by a simple white cloth, while St Joseph has a rough brown cloak.
|
This focus on European subject matter would change in the 18th century, when religious figures would be painted in ponchos and local regalia and placed in native surroundings. The four art schools in Latin America (Quito, Cuzco, Lima, and Alto-Peruvian) flourished in this period. Gold and brocade were incorporated into the paintings. To obtain a gold surface, artists would first apply a layer of red dust and then gold or silver. After this they would rub the surface with an agate and apply a last cover of paint to obtain splendid visual effects.
From the 18th century, religious subjects steadily began to be replaced by other subject matters.
This doesn't mean that spirituality in art disappeared—it simply shifted towards other parts of collective consciousness related to the mystical realm. Myths, history, literature, heroes, symbols, dreams and fantasy, all formed part of this new artistic approach to representing the divine and the superhuman.
Neoclassicism
Neoclassicism developed in France at the end of the 1700s and dominated French art until the early 1800s. Neoclassicism was closely associated with the Revolution. Stylistically, Neoclassical artists valued the formal elements of line and form over color. In subject matter, they attempted to convey moral lessons in great historical events and mythical scenes, reviving a passion for Classical antiquity. Following the lead of the 18th century Enlightenment, Neoclassicism also championed the rights of the individual.
Jacques-Louis David (1748-1825) was one of the leading Neoclassical painters. His Oath of Horatii (1785) illustrated an event in Roman history in which honor and self-sacrifice prevailed. The cities of Rome and Alba agreed to settle their differences through combat between two sets of triplets, rather than all-out war. The figures in the painting wear Roman dress and the scene takes place in a Roman architectural setting. The painting was commissioned by Louis XVI as part of a program aimed at the moral improvement of France.
During the same period in England, the painter Angelica Kauffmann (1741-180) began to paint mythical scenes. Her most famous picture is Amor and Psyche (1765). In the painting, many different styles overlap. The subject is Neoclassical in the sense that it revives a Classical myth, however we could say that the mood was Romantic. Baroque influences can be noted through the loose brushwork and the light and shading, and yet all the detail of jewelry and drapery in the work might be associated with Rococo. Kauffman was a co-founder of the Royal Academy of Arts in England.
 |
Venus Convinces Helen to Go to Paris - Angelica Kauffmann. Kauffmann imparts a velvety quality to her subjects by using pastel colors and gentle brushwork. In this picture she recreates a Greek mythological scene. |
French painter Jean Auguste Dominique Ingres (1780-1867) also painted historical, mythological, and religious subjects. Smooth surfaces and precise drawings characterize his paintings, which are so clearly executed that you feel you can actually touch the skin or fabric depicted.
Some of his mythical paintings include Oedipus and Sphinx (1808) and Jupiter and Thetis (1811). But it was in his Odalisques that Ingres achieved the high point of his painting career. An Odalisque is a harem girl; Ingres would generally depict them nude. In Grande Odalisque (1814), he depicts an idealized reclining nude seen from the back and turning to gaze at the observer. Ingres takes us to an exotic place by incorporating details such as a feathered fan, a fur bed covering, a silk curtain and sheets, and a Turkish pipe.
 |
Grande Odalisque - Jean Auguste Dominique Ingres. The Grande Odalsique illustrates Ingres' love of clarity, which he associates with line, though he was also attracted to the Romantic elements of sensuality and color.
|
Romanticism
In the last lecture we studied those Romantic painters who were socially conscious. Now we will look at some Romantics who emphasized passion, imagination, and intuition, rather than logic, in their work.
The primary goal of the Romantic artists was to express the individual's innermost feelings and emotions. But the Romantics were also interested in the mind as a site of mysterious, unexplained, and possibly dangerous phenomena. For the first time in Western art, Romantics began to portray dreams and nightmares as internal events that were the product of individual imagination, rather than an external supernatural happenings.
In The Nightmare (1785-1790) by Englishman John Henry Fuseli (1741-1825), we can see the Romantic quest for terrifying experiences and dark recesses of the mind. A sleeping woman is haunted in her dreams by a grinning devil that is crouching over her. A luminescent horse glows in the dark and reminds us of Medieval folklore.
 |
The Nightmare (1781) - John Henry Fuseli. Fuseli invites us to enter the realm of the nightmare by incorporating the subject's terrifying dream into the actual space of the bed. The smoky texture and contorted pose of the woman suggests a haunting experience.
|
One artist who combined mysticism with traditional religion was the Englishman William Blake (1757-1827), who had a strong Christian strain in his work.
Blake was a painter and critic who befriended Fuseli and was strongly influenced by Fuseli's strange personality. Blake was a visionary himself: He produced and published his own books of poems with engraved text and hand-colored illustrations (his books were meant to be successors of the Medieval illuminated manuscripts).
 |
Illustration from The Song of Los (1795) - William Blake. Blake was strongly influenced by Christianity. The circle is a recurrent image in Blake's visual language, representing the precision of God's acts.
|
In his hand-colored etching The Ancient of Days (God Creating the Universe) (1794), he depicts a muscular God enclosed in a circle of light. As the architect of the universe, God is shown holding a compass, with his long white hair blown sideways by an unseen wind. One might think that The Ancient of Days stands for the Almighty God, but in Blake's esoteric mythology he stands for the power of reason, which the poet regarded as ultimately destructive, since it obstructs vision and inspiration.
Folk Art
At a more subdued level, religious and spiritual themes continued to be found in folk art, particularly folk art with nature as a subject.
Folk artists are not academically trained; in folk art, forms are usually flattened, proportions unnatural, and imagery generally has no reference to classical tradition. Folk art has been produced in many countries for hundreds of years. Most interesting is American folk art, especially during its most productive period from about 1780 to 1860. Most folk artists worked in small towns in Illinois, New England, New York, and Ohio.
The most famous American folk artist was a Quaker preacher called Edward Hicks (1780-1849), who did around 100 versions of a work called Peaceable Kingdom. Hicks based his painting on a passage of the book of Isaiah in which animals coexist peacefully with humans. The animals and persons in the picture are arranged as if they are on a stage with a fixed front. They have a static quality. In Peaceable Kingdom, Hicks merges the natural landscape with a utopian Garden of Eden.
 |
Peaceable Kingdom (1826) - Edward Hicks. Rather than being drawn into a vast space, the viewer experiences an immediate confrontation with the subjects in this image, especially the wild cats. |
Pre-Raphaelite Brotherhood
The Pre-Raphaelites were a group of seven young English artists and writers who wanted to reform English art. They called themselves Pre-Raphaelites because they admired the simple, informal style of Italian painting before the work of Raphael in the early 1500s.
The leading Pre-Raphaelites were William Holman Hunt, Sir John Everett Millais, and Dante Gabriel Rossetti. They were resolved to paint genuine ideas and represent the world according to nature rather than formal rules. This led them to use striking color and minute, abundant detail. The paintings and poems of the group are often heavily symbolic. Many are set in the distant past, and a number of them have religious and literary themes.
Dante Gabriel Rossetti's (1828-1882) early masterpiece Ecce Ancilla Domini (1850) depicts the annunciation of the Virgin Mary. It radiates an aura of repressed eroticism that would become characteristic of all his work. Elizabeth Siddal, his wife, inspired most of his characters, so all of his subjects have an archetypical femme fatale figure: long red hair, full lips, and a melancholic gaze. She died prematurely, which inspired him to paint Beata Beatrix (1864).
 |
Beata Beatrix (1864) - Dante Gabriel Rossetti. Rossetti uses atmospheric perspective to give Beatrix a mystical appearance. The subject's gesture is one of profound faith at the moment of praying. The elongated neck is characteristic of Rossetti's depictions of women. |
Sir John Everett Millais (1829-1896) painted literary and religious subjects. His work was very detailed and realistic. I have had the fortune of seeing his pictures and they evoke a kind of trance...a desire to walk into the frame and dwell in these mysterious places. In Ophelia (1852) he depicts a beautiful drowned woman, floating in a crystal clear pool. The realistic detail in this painting makes it a disturbing image of reality.
 |
Ophelia (1896) - Sir John Everett Millais. Millais carefully converts Ophelia into part of the pond landscape, by depicting her in as much careful detail as the foliage that surrounds her.
|
For a more in-depth look into another work by Millais, check out the following video tutorial:
Video Tutorial: Religious Theme in Art
English painter William Holman Hunt (1827-1910) painted in a precise, detailed style. Many of his pictures emphasize moral or social symbolism. Hunt strove for authenticity in his work. He made three trips to Egypt and Palestine to paint Biblical scenes with accurate detail. His best-known pictures include The Light of the World (1853-1856), The Awakening Conscience (1853-1854), and The Scapegoat (1854).
Symbolism
Symbolism flourished in France during 1880s and 1890s. It was mainly influenced by Symbolist poets (Baudelaire, Mallarme, Poe) and by fantasies painted by the pre-Raphaelites. The Symbolists attempted to convey the pathos and decadence of the turn of the century and protest the pace of pollution and industrial development.
Instead of fighting these historical forces, the Symbolists retreated into melancholy, dealing with their own personal feelings and imagination in their work. Edvard Munch's painting The Scream, which you saw earlier in the course, is often associated with Symbolism.
Gustav Moreau (1826-1898) created a world of personal fantasy in his paintings. His mystical images evoke long-dead civilizations and mythologies. He treated his subjects with extraordinary sensuousness and created bizarre settings encrusted with jewels. Amongst his famous pictures are Galatea (1880-1881) and The Apparition (Dance of Salome) (1876).
Odilon Redon (1840-1916) had a haunted imagination like Moreau. But his imagery was even more personal and disturbing. Most of Redon's work consists of black and white charcoals and etchings. He developed a distinctive repertoire of weird subjects: strange amoeboid creatures, insects, and plates with human heads inspired by the writings of Edgar Allan Poe. In Eye-Balloon (1882) he depicts a single eyeball removed from its socket and converted into a balloon that floats aimlessly in the sky.
 |
Eye-Balloon (1878) - Odilon Redon. Redon creates a precursor of a Surrealist work in this image by combining two objects that have no other relationship than a similar form. |
Naïve Art
Naïve is a term applied to painting produced in sophisticated societies but lacking formality in representation. However, naïve artists are not necessarily untrained or amateurs as the name may suggest. Some artists deliberately adopt naïve or primitive elements.
Henri Rousseau was a naïve artist who painted in his spare time; he was a customs officer. At first, critics mocked Rousseau's work, but in time he influenced many modern artists. In his painting The Dream (1910), he shows a female nude reclining on a Victorian couch in the middle of the jungle. A dark gray figure emerges from the thick foliage, wearing a colorful tunic and playing an instrument.
 |
The Dream (1910) - Henri Rousseau. |
In The Dream, Rousseau merges the visionary world of a dream, with a detailed depiction of reality (although reality in his painting has an eerie quality). In this sense he synthesizes the two main trends of European art at the turn of the century: subjectivity, the characteristic of the Romantics and Symbolists, and objectivity, the ideal of the Realists and Impressionists.
 |
The Snake Charmer (1907) - Henri Rousseau. Rousseau's lack of formal training can be seen in his plain use of color, the free use of perspective, and the eerie quality of "reality" in his painting.
|
Russian-born artist Marc Chagall (1887-1985) also invoked mystical themes in his naïve painting.
Chagall combined elements of dreams, fantasy, and religion to create paintings with a joyous quality, something quite rare in the art of the 1900s. He incorporated Jewish religious symbols and childhood memories into geometrically divided surfaces. He portrayed objects without concern for their realistic scale. His figures include animals, lovers, and musicians who often floated in the air, sometimes upside down. In Chagall's I and The Village (1911), he weaves together animals, characters, symbols, and memories into a dreamlike vision.
Transcendental Painting
Carrying on the tradition of representing dreamlike and symbolic themes were the Transcendentalists, a unique group of avant-garde painters formed in New Mexico between 1938 to 1941.
These painters were dedicated to the principles of abstraction and inspired by the expanses of South-Western landscape and by Kandinsky's book "Concerning the Spiritual in Art." They chose Transcendentalist as the name of their movement because their aim was to carry painting beyond the appearance of the physical world. They explored imaginative realms and their works were idealistic and spiritual.
Agnes Pelton's works incorporated biomorphic forms and bright colors with shiny effects. In The Blest (1941), a large floral form rises and stretches like an explosion in slow motion. It seems to dissolve as it expands, creating a mystical, floating effect that is related to elusive notions of transcendental spirituality.
Georgia O'Keefe (1887-1986) was married to the photographer Alfred Stieglitz. She is difficult to place in a specific stylistic category, but I think many of her more abstract works share the spiritual qualities of transcendental art. She was influenced by photography and early 20th century abstraction. O'Keefe's Black and White (1930) is an abstract depiction of textures and forms. In her Cow's Skull with Calico Roses (1931), she depicts a dissected skull found in the desserts of New Mexico. If you view it in close up, you will only see abstract forms. Her palette of colors is quite monochromatic—black and whites—with just a few browns.
 |
Black Iris (1926) - Georgia O'Keefe. Notice the painter's approach to scale in this work. By elevating the everyday, O'Keefe's approach to the portrayal of nature was both abstract and spiritual. |
Her flower paintings are her best-known works. She produced sensuously smoothed representations of floral forms, enlarging them into highly abstract designs. These works have a great elegance and rhythmic vitality and are often sexually suggestive.